I'm just shaking my head here. He is being slimey. He bashed Brooke and what he says here still isn't clean, it isn't without murky undertones.

He is generalizing, to the extreme.

He isn't allowing Brooke, or anyone who disagrees with him, to have their own experience.

I'd ask him "How is Brooke misinformed?". Being as she is speaking about her own experience.