Babysteps
If their personalities were equal and they shared many of my same interests, I would still prefer to date #2 (the good looking guy) over guy #1 (aka.. Mr. Pudge).
I guess I'd just rather be seen with a Ferrari rather than a Ford station wagon, lol.
Yes, the Ferrari would have higher maintenance costs but if I am willing (and able) to afford it, why not?
Good luck to you with the online dating... I think the big thing is.. is to stay positive. If you act too sad and down about your life that will scare people off in a very big way.
After all.. what's that saying??
"Laugh and the world laughs with you.... Cry... and you cry alone."
???
With that in mind... I don't think I would tell too much about your problems until you really know for sure that you can trust them and that they truly care about you.
But early on in the relationship, I would just be quiet and play it cool and be upbeat about yourself and your life.
Fake it 'til you make it... that sort of thing.
Missy