View Single Post
 
Old Oct 24, 2009, 04:49 PM
Elysium's Avatar
Elysium Elysium is offline
Where the HELL are we?
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: So Cal
Posts: 3,342
Well...i've never read the book or seen the movie....but I think that what VPowers was getting at maybe was that it MEANT SOMETHING TO HER and it SPOKE TO HER on a level that helped her identify with herself and her disorder.

Even further, I do believe she stated that "it COULD be viewed as a dissociative event".

Amandalouise....I'm not sure what Psych classes or text books you have been reading? Maybe the ones from the 1950's? However...fantasy, whether by an adult OR a child, is considered to be a healthy form of DISSOCIATION that EVERYONE experiences and uses throughout their lives to cope with troublesome issues and provide stimulation to our own senses. Fantasy can become pathological when reality testing is no longer intact...such as with Narcissistic folks, but Fantasy is now being considered a sense of dissociating without the extreme alterations in the integrative functions of consciousness!! If it were to be placed on the continuum of dissociation, it might be placed in/around the extreme left.

Thank you again for reminding us that not everyone fits between the pages of a psychology book, or follows the syllabus of a psych class!!


Oh....and here is a link to one particular Psychological study that discusses the links between Dissociation, Fantasy and Fantasy Proneness. It's quite recent...(2005), and very interesting!!

http://arno.unimaas.nl/show.cgi?fid=4534

Quote:
Originally Posted by amandalouise View Post
I havent seen the movie yet but read the book many times. I didnt take the book as an example of a dissociative event. the boy wasnt under extreme abuse, he wasnt experiencing numbness or feeling like he wasnt real and wasnt feeling like things in his room werent real and he wasnt switching into alternate personalities. in the book it started with he was told to go to his room without dinner because he was mouthing off to his parent. the parent wasnt hitting him, beating on him, the parent wasnt sexually assaulting him or anythnig. he was just told to go to his room for mouthing off. then in his room he pretended he sailed across the sea not floating outside himself not floating and far away from himself. he pretended he had animal friends in far way lands. as far as I know dissociation doesnt include having imaginary friends. then when he smelled food and felt hungry he pretended he was sailing back over the sea leaving his imaginary friends and there in his room was his dinner where his parent had left it. I know that dissociation includes things like feeling numb not feeling things like feeling hungry and smelling dinner, one dissociative disorder specifically states there cant be imaginary friends. So I never took the book to be about a boy dissociating, or a boy having any dissociative disorders. maybe the movie does more speculating and ading things that the book never had nor meant it to be. I dont know but its a far reach for me to see it as a dissociative event if its like the book.
__________________

Last edited by Elysium; Oct 24, 2009 at 05:34 PM. Reason: Added link.
Thanks for this!
WePow, Yoda