Thanks for reply. I didn't want to hurt him and really liked the man, we hit it off so well in all other respects and I don't think I'd find anyone I felt so in tune with again. The natural scent thing, I don't know. There was a musky scent that I didn't find pleasant, like I might expect from a horse or something. It wasn't an unclean smell though, just basic. He's a manly man, the kind who's clean but not into aftershave or deodorant. I know I prefer clean with a hint of aftershave or deodorant. Maybe I'm just not used to real men!