I'm a noobie & promise to go back to "Introductions." So many beautiful comments here for this person's troubles has me teary-eyed & concerned. My husband has a "natural" smell as most men do...I think it just depends on you as a person if that is something you can get used to or not. After working on his truck & playing mechanic, I feel I am even more attracted to his "smell". & Though you may not be completely attracted to this man, have you taken into consideration you may not like what he looks like without a beard? When you love someone, you will love everything about them. After some time, the things you thought you could never get by, may seem as important to you as the person you love. You also mention that there are other reasons...if may help if you were to share with us or give us some idea. It just seems like you really care about this guy & yet, something as insignificant as a scent drew you apart from him. I say, if he's wonderful & amazing...don't let him go. If the other reasons you don't seem very willing to share are more extreme & he seems to be pulling away...be on your way.