I think we should have some of "both" types of therapy as we are "whole" people, not just our bodies or just our heads and I don't think one way or another is better/worse or complete in itself! I think it's like the nature/nuture controversy because there seems to be a lot of trying to make discreet sections of ourselves in the West. We talk of physical, mental, emotional, spiritual, etc. but one can't really separate those out I don't think.