Theoretically, no one is above the law. I urge you to test that theory. First, call the Chief of Police to explain what is going on with one of his officers. Ask the Chief to help you get your property back.

If the officer does not have the funds to pay for the refrigerator, you are entitled to it as long as it was not intended as a gift. In addition, the officer should be responsible for a fair rental fee during the time he used it. You might find out what a fair rental is for the refrigerator by calling a rental store.

Next, I would call the Mayor and explain what is going on. Tell the Mayor you are concerned that the Chief will look out for his officer first. Ask the Mayor to call the Chief to see that a fair and thorough investigation is done.

Then call a reporter at the local newspaper to ask if the paper is interested in publishing a story about your ordeal. If not, write a letter to the editor.

My next phone call would be to the City or County Attorney, whichever has jurisdiction, to find out if there is probable cause to believe a crime has been committed. Theft of property is defined in some jurisdictions thusly:

Theft of property. A person is guilty of theft if he:
Knowingly takes or exercises unauthorized control over, or makes an unauthorized transfer of an interest in, the property of another with intent to deprive the owner thereof;

If you still have not gotten satisfaction, I would write to your state and federal representatives to express you deep disappointment regarding how those who are charged with upholding the law are allowed to so blatantly break it.

One final caveat. Demand to be paid in guaranteed funds like a cashier's check or bank money order. If the officer gives you a check there is nothing to prevent him from stopping payment on it.

Good luck.