I have only personally been on Depakote. I have so far found it to work best for me. After the new year calms donw, I am going to mention getting put on it again. The Depakote only put on 30 pounds or so for me, but the benefits definitely outweighed the weight

I just didnt like it at the time, but after this last little 'ride' of not having stable meds, weight is NOT an issue. I can understand some out there who did have a larger weight gain side effect. It is a personal choice. I know that I need to live a little healthier of a lifestyle, so going on it for me is almost motivation to eat healthy so my weight CAN'T gain.
I wish you the best of luck in whatever choice you do make.
On the Topic of Depakote, has anyone ever heard of it being used for Rapid Cyclers?
__________________
“Whatever you are, be a good one.”
- Abraham Lincoln