View Single Post
 
Old Sep 13, 2011, 07:13 AM
Ygrec23's Avatar
Ygrec23 Ygrec23 is offline
Still Alive
 
Member Since: Apr 2010
Location: Florida
Posts: 2,853
Quote:
Originally Posted by FooZe View Post
What I saw Mead and MacNeil doing was bringing a lot of experience to what they were telling us: such-and-such approach may sound like a good idea at first but here's what usually happens when you try it... If that's not the result you want, better take a different route or at least be prepared to change course partway through.
Well, FooZe, they certainly did bring a lot of experience, and they certainly also had given a lot of very intelligent thought to what they were saying and proposing. Have you ever seen their philosophy in action? I haven't, so I don't know. I'm entirely in favor of the spirit of what they suggest. I just wonder whether it could be put into practice without creating an elite who really run things, although that of course would be entirely against the spirit of their proposals.

I would be very interested to know about where and with what success such ideas have been used in reality. I think that our society, at least, is so saturated in ideas of authority and hierarchy that there would be many, many people (a very significant percentage, if not a majority) who just "wouldn't get it." And they do note expressly the particular problem of any such group with their ideas interfacing (in a hospital for example) with any traditional structures. I don't know. I doubt that in my lifetime I'll ever have the opportunity to join such a community. Take care!
__________________
We must love one another or die.
W.H. Auden
We must love one another AND die.
Ygrec23