Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfgang34
And inadvertently creates some of the cases of mental disorders in members presented on this site? In particular: Depression, ADHD/ADD, Bipolar and Narcissistic Personality Disorder?
There seems to be a growing interest in the "anti-school" movement, made both by students, parents and teachers alike. Mainly in their belief that schools wreck the psychological development of children and teens. A serious problem overlooked by many in their eyes.
Sites like School-Survival, the Educational Freedom Education, the National Youth Rights Association, Psychology Today and authors like John Taylor Gatto, Alfie Kohn, and Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt argue that the educational system we have in place does more harm than good. Instead of pushing kids to fight for their dreams and to be creative and open-minded while doing so, many schools today demands obedience and only seeks to create thoughtless workers for the ones in charge (Whether that means the government, authorities, or corporate/business leaders.)
Thoughts Opinions?
|
Maybe it depends on the school system and the culture in which it is located. I have a problem with the idea of "kids to fight for their dreams". I don't see anything wrong with
well-placed obedience. I live in the US and where I work now definitely has an entire tier of workers that the organization wants to be 'thoughtless' -- or I should say like drones, doing exactly what the job requires with no questions asked. But those drones are
also expected to innovate and do more with less and come up with better ideas to do things (which the bosses then steal and present as their own ideas). Which is why I am making plans to get out of that environment. Why? Because
my education did not prepare me, nor do I want to be, anyone's slave. I'm inclined to think the local culture creates the school system rather than the other way around. I enjoyed school and still do; although I should point out I am not young anymore. I am often in classrooms with young people who don't give any appearance of having enquiring minds; who have a small fund of knowledge gained through personal curiosity; who don't read for fun and who don't care about issues that they do not believe personally affect themselves. I work alongside many adults who are the same way. I don't think school can beat an enquiring mind into someone. I think bipolar disorder, ADHD/ADD and Narcissistic Personality Disorder may be found in people in school systems, but school systems don't cause those problems. They might make them worse but so would other major life stressors like marriage, gaining or losing a job, or moving to a new city. I'd specifically like to stress that I don't encourage anyone to "fight for their dreams" and I don't think it is random that you chose the word "fight"--I've seen the students who believe in clawing and biting their way to the top and they are miserable, miserable people.