You may bet that Frau T expected you to not be 100 percent honest. I think all clients tell white lies in their first appt, I would go back to her as it sounds like she really does care and have a genuine interest and maybe tell her in next session(if you decide to go) that you were a little overwhelmed by all the questions and you couldn't think straight. If you can feel comfortable with her I say go for it, but maybe you would like to try AOL T once to see what he is like and keep your options open.
PS, I love the names you gave your T, very funny