I have to admit, I'm a bit confused as to how the supervisor could have someone come to your house and confiscate the pills. They are not illegal, and you have a valid prescription for them. So, for someone to come and take them without your consent, would be theft, right?

I think I'd talk to your p-doc and if you're concerned about having extra medication on hand, ask her to hold on to it for you. Or, ask a friend or family member to hold on to it. If these are pills that you expect to need at a later date, I certainly wouldn't dispose of them.

While I understand your T's concern, I think perhaps what's being asked is unreasonable. There are other options for making sure that you don't have access to excess medication. Besides, you just stated that you've gotten new prescriptions for meds....so it's not like you won't have some on hand anyway. Is your T going to some how control those as well?