I also use my company's EAP and it's excellent. I'm glad you're offered that benefit. I would say that you see the therapist and if you like the office, then make an appointment to see the psychiatrist there. If you feel that your quality of care isn't up to your standards with your current doctor, then you should find a new one. It's perfectly reasonable and responsible to have a doctor that you feel is on your side and works the way you need them to work with you.