Glad I've not been profiled for this. I am very ill-defined by generalized assumptions based on my demographics.

In answer to the thread title, yes. But why? Really got thinking about it and had some thoughts on why some shared housing works and some doesn't. It's rather long (careful what you ask, mm, 'cause I just might answer in epic form ), but probably worth reading if shared housing is something anyone's considering. In assessing why this is working so well (unexpectedly -- remember, I didn't think shared housing was for me), I think if people really thought about their particular needs, expectations and personal quirks in the following matters, it would greatly increase the odds for finding a good match. Chime in if you think of other things.

Structure : H-B, your saying you found your college situation good because it was well-structured made me think about that aspect. Mine is very unstructured and I like it that way. It only works though because everyone here is mature and does what needs doing without being asked or told to do so. Many situations are not that way. I wouldn't like a highly structured environment for 3 reasons.
1) I cannot stand being told what to do and when to do it. It's not that I don't want to do the thing, not at all. Even as a teenager my thinking was, "I will do this chore gladly -- and thoroughly--of my own volition. Telling me to do it takes all the fun and giving out of it. It becomes just an obligation." Being keenly observant made "being told" rather insulting as well.
2) To have such a structured arrangement would suggest that it was needed. Which very likely would mean the other people were not of my nature. So that wouldn't be great as I hate having to point out the obvious. Or play the heavy. Which I don't, and instead end up doing it all myself, which over the years many have been more than happy to count on me doing. It's a recipe for resentment. Especially if the arrangement encourages the attitude of "It's someone else's turn so it's ok to leave a big mess since I'm not the one who has to deal with it".
3) Sometimes I just plain can't manage doing things. I more than make up for it when I can though(!) That work style doesn't jibe well with regimentation.

Boundaries: Respecting others' space. That's a huge one. I don't invade others' space and I sure as hell don't want them intruding on mine! That refers to both physical space and personal boundaries. Also, is food separate? Shared partially or in full? Swiped?

Trust: Definitely related to above and necessary, as not having it really stresses me out. Even if I do trust, my space must be lockable. Are others cognizant of safety? Locking outside doors? It's bad enough for me as a checker. Wondering if someone has gone behind me and is careless is crazy-making.

Degree of personal space: I need my very own very separate burrow. Others prefer more interaction and closer proximity. Shared space is fine and an integral part of shared housing. Just how much separation is wanted will vary from person to person.

How much and what kind of social life the place has as an entity: Quiet? Party house? Big, medium or small gatherings? Is anyone majorly gregarious with people coming and going all the time, or only a few visitors that you are introduced to? Do you particularly like or loathe the others' tastes in music? If I like it, loud is fine. If I hate it, I'll be crawling out of my skin (and might get ugly about it).

Are there kids, pets or regular visitors? Do you like 'em? Trust 'em?

Level of cleanliness and/or organization: This is one that I am surprisingly flexible on, especially considering that I'm kind of a neat freak. BUT. I realize that this is my issue and do not hold others to it. My space is tidy, but it's ok with me if shared areas less so, and I don't give a hoot what people do with their own space. AS LONG AS we're not talking bugs. Rather serious phobia there, and I can't set it aside. So much so that it is the #1 consideration in housing for me.

How are bills handled?: Included? Shared? If so, what do they run?

Do you care what hours others keep? Do they mind the ones you keep?

Some other things that others might find apply... As much as there are things about living alone that would be appealing, I know that I'd be a much bigger danger to myself in such a situation. (Psych agrees and thinks this is a good way to go.) Feeling greater security especially when on edge, and knowing that if I have a medical emergency, someone will probably be there to help. Also, the considerably lower rent allows me to live in a neighborhood that I really like, but otherwise couldn't really afford. That's worth a lot sometimes, especially in terms of getting out and about in fighting depression. Liking it makes going more likely.

(Sorry such a grammatical and POV hodgepodge...)