First things first....Make this a fact finding mission. Ask the editor what he has to offer you in the way of hours of work, benefits, moving assistance (yes you can ask for that if they want you bad enough) personal time, sick leave, bonuses, etc etc etc. Then make a list of pros and cons for each job. Be honest about them, then compare them. What does your gut tell you to do? Tell the editor you need a bit of time to consider his offer because you want to make the right choice for you and the newspapers. He should appreciate that Good luck with your decision making!