Tough scenario, as a suicide survivor and as a suicide attempt survivor, I understand that it serves a purpose. It is sad that for some people, it would take something so extreme to fix the mess inside. I understand this anguish and hell that life can bring. My husband says it is a sin because it takes your life into your own hand, not God's. I figure, if God is God, He knows already when we die whether we take our own life, or it's taken for us. I do not think that suicide is as selfish as everyone says it is. If someone lives with such demons inside that they would rather die than go on for one more second...I would find it hard to not let him/her choose.