View Single Post
 
Old May 31, 2013, 12:04 PM
anneo59's Avatar
anneo59 anneo59 is offline
Grand Poohbah
 
Member Since: Sep 2012
Location: US
Posts: 1,615
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trippin2.0 View Post
How is this imbalance measured? What type of scale is used? I want the physical proof. If we are imbalanced, why do these FDA approved chemicals not restore the balance for all that have tried them? And no, don't throw me that "we all have different chemistry" line, because I'm pretty sure all brains work the same, so if the meds were actually FOR treating the things they are treating, it would surely make a "solid" difference.

Take injectable contraceptives for example (synthetic hormones) women react differently to it, some gain / lose weight, some are weight neutral, some continue there cycle, some don't, some lose hair, others don't BUT 1 thing all these women have in common is that they are all being protected against unwanted pregnancy, even though their hormone levels are different and side effects of synthetic hormones differ.

Better yet, if chemical imbalance is factual, or even just very nearly so, why are we urged to take seizure meds as mood stabilizers for bipolar? Shouldn't there be a bp med by now if its as simple as "chemical imbalance", after all, who are more "imbalanced" than we? Seizure meds indeed WTH? I'm not having seizures I won't take flu medicine for a headache, so why am I expected to do that??

To me? Chemical Imbalance just sounds like a nice way for a dr to say "Something's really off about you, but heck if I know what exactly it is and how the hell to fix it, but here take these twice a day for forever"...

PLEASE NOTE: These are my views and opinions, this post is not meant to be judgemental toward anyone going the med route I tried it too, and just chose to change course.
Imho, there are many involved in this controversy, I believe, w varying agendas, and and not all with their main concerns being mental health improvement. I have a feeling, and some of this may be good for the patients, or should I say medical consumers, that this argument will be around a good while now. I am actually old enuff to remember many more treatments other than pharmacology, and insurance not playing a major role here. So, now we may be having another shift for a while. We do live in interesting times!
Thanks for this!
Rose76