I've received counseling from various persons . . . Ph.D. in psychology, Psy.D., MSW, art therapist, LPC, and a clergyman.

I think all that matters (determining who is a good counselor) is: (1) empathy (2) years of practice (3) connection with patient (4) not too busy to help and listen.

You can't read those things on a certificate.

I think referrals are a good thing. Have you asked around for recommendations on who will provide you outstanding care?