I WOULD feel good, but it does not mean that you SHOULD feel good. The difference between would and should is important because there is no RIGHT way to feel - you feel what you feel. That I WOULD feel good in no way means that you SHOULD feel good, TOO.

Also, it could be that they just weren't the right kind of guys for you in some aspect, and that in the future attention from better suited guys WOULD feel good for you.