Did you read the first couple of posts I made? I clearly said what my intent here was. Let me repeat for you so u don't have to re-read. I am introducing a alternative opposing perspective regarding BPD that has been and is currently being hotly debated by top mental health officials. I bring this to the table because a lot of people may not otherwise ever be aware such opinions existed. For the sake of providing a fair treatment for this topic I am merely playing the devil's advocate. I also clearly said I nether agree or disagree with this. I am focusing on the side that most people would never hear about. A lot of people have provided really good arguments against this view in this thread. So I'm not really sure what your asking me here to do?