Well we are all entitled to have our opinions...I feel any dr or psychiatrist who cannot approach treatment options on a case by case basis, veiwing each patient as an individual are a little out of their minds. The failure rate rate for psychiatric meds is really quite high, to assume everyone would be helped by meds is a mistake. And a common mistake dr's make time and time again considering many of them do know the rate of failure for such meds. The medications are not excluded from being extremely dangerous. Ad's have a black box warning for a reason.
Also considering that we have only theory to work with here and not fact, it seems premature to close other doors.
Past experience is not always the best indicator of the future either, people do change, just as the rest of the universe does.
I can understand where you are coming from but there are more than two sides to a coin.