Thread: Dreams
View Single Post
 
Old Jan 11, 2007, 11:12 AM
Perna's Avatar
Perna Perna is offline
Pandita-in-training
 
Member Since: Sep 2006
Location: Maryland
Posts: 27,289
Dr. Clay wrote:

"Some insight is possible, but there is a risk that one will attribute more significance to his/her dreams than they warrant. Remember, it is possible that the dream images are rather meaningless neuronal brain activity. This was discussed in the "general idea" section. Besides the dream context being of dubious significance, other disadvantages are the time involved, the long delay of most benefits, the uncertain effectiveness of the "dream analysis" work, and perhaps the psychological stress involved. Being upset by the dreams or their implications are the only known dangers." -- Chapter 15?

Slightly biased against dream analysis :-) How can one attribute more significance than is warranted? Isn't that up to the dreamer, both the significance and the warranting and able to tell others something about the dreamer? Too, I would think it could be a literal danger if you attribute more significance than is warranted, give a flying saucer concrete existence, for example, and act on it or think someone else is going to be on an accident and don't let them "go" wherever or respond for themselves?

But I don't believe our selves do anything consciously differently than we do unconsciously; like hypnotism and daydreams, we're not going to suddenly believe in flying saucers if we weren't likely to beforehand or think we can know the future if we didn't think that before. I think dreams "clarify" things about ourselves. I don't think there is such thing as "meaningless" neuronal brain activity as I don't think my brain/self does anything "meaningless." A cigar is sometimes just a cigar but that, in itself, is meaninful. Freud did die of his mouth cancer and if he'd "seen" the cigar in dreams or otherwise and had attributed significance to it, might have helped himself?

Last night I dreamed of my therapist again, whom I haven't seen for a year and a half, second time this week. How meaningless/random can that be for me? I was trying to please her and enthusiastic about my chances for doing so.
__________________
"Never give a sword to a man who can't dance." ~Confucius