The attachment between you and your therapist sounds natural and good. You are sharing really deep emotions and wounds, and a great therapist will care about you in the midst of that. It would be concerning if you did NOT feel your therapist cares. Sharing the same faith may add an extra level to your experience that is HEALTHY. If you did not feel that connection with your therapist, if you did not feel that your therapist really cares, you would not get nearly as much out of therapy. (This is supported by research.) Sounds like you have the right person for you. Move forward with confidence. (From: Another therapist who cares)