View Single Post
 
Old Apr 03, 2014, 11:33 AM
growlithing's Avatar
growlithing growlithing is offline
Magnate
 
Member Since: May 2013
Location: Boston
Posts: 2,608
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1914sierra View Post
I've honestly never really noticed whether T uses "why" questions or not, but my gut is that he does. I've never felt he manipulates his language much with me. I'm not one to feel judged by a "why" question though, so it wouldn't be on my radar. I like "why" questions myself. I work with "why" questions in terms of character motivation and language usage, etc. in my teaching all the time, so those kinds of conversations are just part and parcel to analysis, and what is therapy if not analysis of the self.

I know that both LCM and school T definitely have asked me "why" before. I ask myself why all the time. I think it is a good question and I also think that the other people on the thread had some very valid points because in the context of how I used "why", if could have come across as very accusatory and judgmental.

I feel like it might be a question to be careful with with is essentially what LCM said last night. Like in the hypothetical question I asked myself, wording it differently might be beneficial but it didn't matter because I didn't notice. It probably also is something T's might have to use on a case by case basis. I imagine it can be more or less helpful to some people than others and maybe even offensive or harsh to other people.

I feel like it is another one of those minor semantics games that makes a world of difference. The issue with semantics is that different words feel different to different people. I've run into this a lot on other threads in another forum on PC where words just gave a slightly different meaning to everyone that reads it and no one hesitates to point it out. Language is interesting because it manages to be universal to people sharing a common language and yet completely personal and subjective at the same time and I can't think of many things that do that.

I guess that's just something T's have to be really super attentive to. I curse a lot and I remember school T adjusting to match my language and cursing more when we were just getting started working together. Which is awkward/kinda cute because she is one of those people that doesn't curse with a natural inflection making it sound really forced.

Tangent ended.
Thanks for this!
Lauliza