View Single Post
 
Old Apr 13, 2014, 08:28 PM
rockgal's Avatar
rockgal rockgal is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: United States
Posts: 112
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sister Rags View Post
I wish I had faith that an experienced p-doc could handle my benzo w/d. I've been on k-pin for 20 years with 3 very unsuccessful attempts at withdrawal. No p-doc worked any magic for me, because there is no magic pill or substance that can help ease benzo w/d. Statistically, most people have tolerance and withdrawal problems that are hellish and disabling.

You've gone off the xanax then have returned to taking it. I would like to hear from someone who has been on long-term benzo use and successfully withdrawn and stayed off benzos. Benzo w/d is not bad for everyone, but for most people benzo w/d's are likened to heroin w/d's, except that heroin w/d does pass after a couple of weeks and is very seldom life-threatening. And there are meds to replace the opiate. Benzo w/d sickness can last for years and can be life-threatening. Look, why do you think most p-docs don't want to prescribe benzos? There are reasons. they're not just trying to be cruel to their patients, ya know?
I've never had problems getting benzos prescribed by my pdocs, nor have pdocs I've seen for consults blinked at the fact that I've taken them. And these have been among the best pdocs in the areas I have lived (major metro areas), one being a national expert. So not all pdocs are benzophobic - many do prescribe them if they think they are a good choice for a particular patient. It wasn't my idea to take them. They were considered a good option for me. I find low dose benzos far easier to deal with than SSRI's, which are problematic for me in a number of ways (I know they're fantastic for many people).

I really am sorry you've had such a rough ride, and I certainly believe your account of your experience. I do question your generalizations (statistically, most...). They seem overly broad and are not backed up by bias-free, peer reviewed literature.

Again, I certainly believe benzo discontinuation can be a real problem for some people. However, my pdocs have been of the opinion that these are well-understood, well-vetted drugs that can work very well for long term use for some people. I am an example of someone who has difficulty tolerating side effects of many meds, does tolerate benzos very well, and has very little difficulty getting off drugs (builds up little tolerance or dependence). I'm also very sensitive, which means I get a lot of effect out of a low dose. So Xanax works out well for me, and I feel comfortable that if my stress and anxiety dwindled even further, I could stop altogether with no ill effects. If I don't need it, I can go days at a clip without it, with no problems. Your experience is obviously very different and very miserable, and definitely underscores that there is a huge, huge range of responses to drugs, which makes pdocs' jobs pretty challenging I think.