View Single Post
 
Old Jun 21, 2014, 11:09 AM
outlaw sammy outlaw sammy is offline
Account Suspended
 
Member Since: Feb 2014
Location: Denver, Colorado
Posts: 245
Quote:
Originally Posted by wildflowerchild25 View Post
Like the other posters said, bipolar is not an excuse for bad behavior. If I get in a rage and hit or verbally abuse my husband, I sure as hell apologize for it. If I just said oh, I was manic, deal with it, I'm sure we'd be divorced.

And also, I feel i someone is not doing verything in his or her power to address their condition then they ARE responsible for the episodes. I'm not saying everyone has to be on medication, but if you are not treating your condition through any means then you're not taking responsibility. I've done this. I've abused my medication, I've stopped taking it AMA, I've refused to use coping skills, I've done all that jazz. In those cases I feel I'm responsible for the episodes I induced. AGAIN I am NOT saying everyone needs meds, I'm saying that ignoring your condition is not a responsible way to handle it. To use your analogy, an epileptic would be responsible for seizures if he/she refused treatment.

Just my opinion, possibly an unpopular one.
Sorry, but an episodic event (i.e. insanity) due to bipolar disorder is an absolute affirmative defense against legal responsibility for a crime. In other words, whatever a person says or does while mentally incapacitated (i.e. insane) is beyond their control and thus, not their responsibility. Certainly, the offender who deliberately refuses medication, like the intoxicated offender, hasn't any defense due to the voluntary nature of their mental incapacitation.