Brad Pitt is a man of average attractiveness who has been a benefactor of an extremely good PR campaign. I have known numerous men more attractive than he is. Plus, his facial expression is sort of dumb - that might be because I am mostly seeing him on tabloid pictures with Jolie and a bunch of kids, so he might simply be overwhelmed by having to shepherd so many kids at once. Maybe what looks dumb to me is overwhelm in reality. At any rate, he is not an inch above average.

Daniel Day-Lewis, when young, was far more attractive and with more intelligence to his face, too. He won 3 Oscars and Brad Pitt won only one. That actually speaks more of his acting than looks, but I thought I'd point it out.