My guess is that this issue is more about being skinny than being tall, am I right? A lot of women like tall guys. However, I have had more than one guy get offended when I called him "skinny" because apparently that's not necessarily a good thing for a guy?

Personally, I don't like "skinny" guys. I like fit guys who are of normal to slightly above normal weight. But "skinny" guys, no, as it just doesn't feel good to be with them physically.