Something tells me this goes beyond just the shirt.
But did she see you wear the shirt? Sometimes that makes all the difference. A friend and I went around at a thrift store and picked out the ugliest shirts we could find and wondered how anyone could ever wear them. No word of a lie, an attractive, young woman picks ALL of them (she hadn't heard our conversation) and them some we missed and ROCKED them. Like, she actually looked great lol. So, it really can depend.