I tried over 30 and stuck with two who I did not completely despise. The second one is better than the first one and if I was only going to see one, it would be the second one because I don't leave feeling worse. The first one I usually do.
Is it possible to try some others - particularly if you are not this guy's demographic client. I would never let any of them talk to anyone else.
Getting rid of this one sounds like a good plan - is the amount he charges the going rate in your area? It is more than double the rate in the area I live.