No matter how well-intended you are, a site like this (and others) in which people disclose the most intimate details of their therapeutic encounters where they may not be able to IRL and be understood should be met IMHO with as much support as possible. Babbling about theory and hypotheticals in response to someone's intimate details needing support and understanding . . . well, it's just not my cup of tea.

Maybe there are other sites and forums that are better suited for the kind of theory and debate you seem to want to engage in, but I would hope posters would not using Pinksoil's intimate post to pick apart and analyze for that purpose.