I think you did well with the second person you saw, not going back. Often the initial session is free; I'd just keep checking out different therapists until you find one you would like to work with. Some people like the therapist talking more and some, less, and some therapists, especially (I assume) younger ones or those without much experience are still working out how to adjust to each person and figure out how to interact with them that first time just as we are trying to figure out to interact with them in return.