View Single Post
 
Old Jan 13, 2016, 10:40 AM
ScientiaOmnisEst's Avatar
ScientiaOmnisEst ScientiaOmnisEst is offline
Poohbah
 
Member Since: Sep 2015
Location: Upstate NY
Posts: 1,130
Quote:
Originally Posted by Angelique67 View Post
Oh, thank you. I hadn't seen this before. My thoughts on that are, firstly, I used to believe psychiatry is evil. But the psychiatry of today is much more compassionate in a general way than it used to be, and hopefully it will just get more so. When I was in college in the 1970s, that was my first experience of psychiatry. It was pretty bad. I spent the next 35 years avoiding psychiatry at all costs, and suffering from my conditions, but free of meds. Granted I never had anything new happen in those years. I never had hallucinations, etc. But I did still have my original illness.

When I began seeing a new psychiatrist (for meds I had been taking, prescribed by a GP), I did not trust the Atypical antipsychotics. That was too bad because a new thing did start, I did begin to have hallucinations. Fast forward about 7 years, and now I couldn't get by without an aap med. The hallucinations I had were absolute torture.

This is getting to be a lot of rambling, sorry. Can't organize my thoughts well anymore.

In conclusion, although for most of my life I believed psychiatrists and their meds were the devil, I now am very grateful for the meds because they rescued me from horrible suffering. I wouldn't be taking meds if there were nothing wrong with me. I'm not sure I faithfully addressed your question. :/
I was more concerned about the articles' claims that mental illness doesn't exist, or that it's wrong to help suicides. That what we call mental illness is just "life problems" or natural variations in human experience. Or another argument that pathologizing certain behaviors infringes on people's rights (because you're basically saying it's wrong to think or do certain things - if mental diagnoses were laws, we'd live in a fascist dystopia where thoughtcrime is rampant). Or indeed, the argument that we only see things as disorders because of our culture and there's actually nothing wrong.