View Single Post
 
Old Feb 20, 2016, 04:07 PM
BayBrony's Avatar
BayBrony BayBrony is offline
Grand Poohbah
 
Member Since: Dec 2013
Location: usa
Posts: 1,847
Quote:
Originally Posted by Walkedthatroad View Post
I used your relationship as an example because that is what you have continuously used overtime to make your argument. I too, use my personal experiences when I post. In fact, I was told by the powers that be on PC that is what they want.

In my speech community "Rail = Reproach" I believe that is what you have been doing regarding your former therapist and her profession. You have a right to do that. I pass no judgement. I just stated a fact.

Re: Sue Elkind's quote above. As my therapist told me there is one major difference between an infant/parent relationship compared to a client/therapist relationship: Cognition.
For Me although I am VERY attached and VERY vulnerable with my T I'd never liken it to mother/infant. I'm an adult. I came into therapy with a career, my own coping skills ( some of them really crappy ones, but still), the fundamental abilities the infants and even older children lack---i could refuse to see my T and I would still be fed,clothed, housed, able to communicate, etc eyc---, my own adult relationships ( some of them again, crappy. But still). , my own view of the world etc

To liken yourself to an infant and the T to a mother is to give the T WAY too much power. Yes I was severely abused starting as a very young child( my T says " you were fighting for your own survival from the day you were born). I failed to form any healthy attachment, I didn't.learn object constancy or how to comfort myself in non self destructive ways and I needed a T to help me learn how to attach and experience love and stop trying to destroy myself instead of directing anger at my abusers. But I didn't need her to plan a vacation, buy a car, get a new pet, meet a new friend, try a new sport, buy new business equipment, explore different religions etc etc because I am.also a free adult.

To me the two are nothing alike. My mother tried to drown me before I was old enough to even be able to clearly communicate what had happened to another person. My mother abused me at an age where the only other people I even knew all knew my mother better and would never believe me. At an age where she was literally large enough to kill me. Where she could control whether I got food, whether I could leave the house, where she was in the room with the pediatrician so I couldn't tell that she scrubbed my genitals til they bled.

My T doesn't have anything like that power.

To say a T has that kind of power over an adult is ridiculous and denies the real powerlessness abused children experience
Hugs from:
feralkittymom, unaluna
Thanks for this!
feralkittymom, justdesserts, Rive., ScarletPimpernel, unaluna