Maven, I see where you have researched the printers, and basically they all do pretty much the same thing in the same way, some with different bells and whistles. What you might consider doing is researching the printer INK cartridges that the printers you like, use. That varies widely and usually is where the real cost of printing lies. Not all cartridges are the same. You can pay more for one type a very inexpensive printer uses, and though you pay more, it makes fewer copies. That's what you need to compare... how many copies of black/white and how many copies of color the cartridge makes.

Now, beware of CompuUsa as you cannot return anything there once you open it, without a big restock fee. Otherwise, you have to just keep returning and taking a replacement, no matter how many times the component fails. Circuit City has better items. Have you considered online shopping with QVC or HSN, what about Office Depot?

Good wishes on your hunt!