I think you should trust your instincts too. However...I would not let PC talk of "wonderful" therapists influence you. Some of those therapists are indeed wonderful, some of it is sugarcoating or idealization, some of those wonderful therapists will turn out to be not so wonderful (if they haven't already).

The real question is, is she a good therapist for you as she is? Not, could she be more like other people's therapists? She is who she is, and while she might change small things to help you, she probably will not change her approach to therapy.