I see a therapist who does not usually talk about religion unless I bring it up. Why you were not informed of the Christian foundation of this counselor - I am not sure. I would firstly discuss your concerns with the current counselor telling her/him that prayer is most definitely important but that you need another approach to help you therapeutically. If they fail to make any real change in approach then I would definitely search for another therapist in the area. Doing a phone interview before going in and seeing them could be helpful to see where they stand and what they offer.