View Single Post
 
Old Sep 30, 2016, 01:30 AM
Cyllya Cyllya is offline
Member
 
Member Since: Sep 2016
Location: Phoenix AZ USA
Posts: 127
I share your disdain for the DSM, but since it's so prolific, I can't really fault other resources that use it. Especially since these kinds of internet things can't really provide any help directly besides recommending that you go talk to a doctor/therapist about whatever problem it thinks you have, it pretty much has to be based on the DSM, because the doctor/therapist is going to be using the DSM.

For example, anytime I see someone asking about a problem that sounds like initiation deficit (a matter close to my metaphorical heart), I'd like it if I could tell them it's called initiation deficit, tell them the name of a condition that entails that symptom, recommend they see a doctor about that condition, maybe mention some common treatments. But there doesn't seem to be anything in the DSM that has initiation deficit as part of the diagnostic criteria. So instead, I give them some ADHD-related anecdotes and maybe some suggestions on how to reword the description of the problem so it sounds like a concentration issue.

DSM aside, the test often asked some weird questions. I think there were a few where you have to be knowledgeable about psychology/psychiatry in order to understand what kind of info it was looking for. (I think this is sometimes a problem in actual diagnostic interviews too!)

Quote:
Originally Posted by MyTorturedSoul View Post
Here's what's going on:
people often use the terms mental illness, mental disorder, and mental disease interchangeably. This is bad, because they all mean different things.

Mental illness: social construction that focuses on society
Mental disorder: social construction that focuses on the individual
Mental disease: a physical problem in the brain. The only scientific phrase out of the three.

An example of a disease of the mind: Alzheimer's!
An example of a mental illness: Depression
An example of a mental disorder: Pedophilia
The kind of depression I have would fit your definition of a mental disease... but pretty much all of the depression-related DSM diagnoses could apply to that kind of disease OR to being sad because your life sucks.