Hello here today: I can't offer any feedback with regard to the situation you describe with your daughter. With regard to your having inserted a request for feedback in another person's thread... not knowing any of the details... I don't know as there is much I can say. On the face of it, no, I don't know why that would be considered out of line. On the other hand, it's kind-of one of those things where you get (or don't get) what you get... maybe something... maybe nothing.

I personally don't subscribe to any of the threads I reply to. (And I seldom post threads of my own.) So, if anyone comments on a reply I write on someone's thread, the chances are I'll never see it. So, you never know what the situation may be with another member here on PC. As a result, at least from my perspective, it's fine to ask for feedback. But you have to do it with the idea that you may get something & you may not. That's just the way it is.