Thanks so much for all the great suggestions! I am definitely printing out this thread.
I do like to take my girls to pick out the movies with me, but we often wander around the store, not being able to decide on anything or to know if any of the titles are any good. (I stopped going to movies when I became a mom in 1990.) It will be so useful to have some ideas before we set foot inside the store.
We saw Premonition last night (with Sandra Bullock). My video store doesn't have The Fly.