I think I have added to this discussion all that I can. The links I gave you starting with the one on page 16, were articles that posed the for and against. The idea being read them and if you learn something from them, thats good. If not then disregard them, but don't pick them to pieces so that someone else cannot learn or form there own opinion about the articles. I think ((Chocolatelover)) learned something that will help her on her journey. If you check and do further reading at innerexplorations, it is mentioned several times that Jung was uncomfortable with Christianity and belief in God. I do not know if he was or was not. I never met him to ask him. It seems we always can find fault with others writings when what they say is different then what we want to believe. But when we put up that wall, we can not learn anything either. I try to read and think about things said, pay attention to the important points and disregard the things I question. That is how we learn new things. If we go at it as only (in my opinion), we lose the battle before we have fought the war. And so do the ones who have followed along behind us.