I'm sorry you didn't feel that connected to her. But I'd definitely give her a second session. I feel like the first intake session is often just getting the basic info about a client.

Out of curiosity, was it the typical 45-50 minutes or longer? I liked that my intake session with T2 was 90 minutes--let me get past the initial nervousness and feel a bit more comfortable with him. I was definitely very unsure the first 30-45 minutes. But then later in the session I felt more comfortable and liked him in second session. It can be difficult getting used to a different therapeutic style, or even just someone else's pacing when they talk (T2 seems to talk in a slower, more measured way--while MC talks pretty fast much of the time--I guess T1 is in between).

I'd keep looking in the meantime, in case this new T doesn't end up working out, or if you find someone who is a better fit.

I think what's different in your situation compared to mine is that you still mostly liked RoboT, so probably want someone like him, where I'm feeling dissatisfied with T1, so want someone different.