I would look at this issue from another perspective, seeing as we're not private investigators, nor is our community a place where we require people to be truthful at all times about everything they write. We believe trust is earned by people sharing truthful things about themselves, and until a member has earned your trust, you should treat them as you might treat anyone you don't know.

We can't indict (or suspend or ban) people based on hunches.

And where did your belief come from? A set of verifiable facts, or a set of hunches that may have no connection to facts? Just because someone's story doesn't sound "right" to you doesn't mean it is untruthful. Are they a new(er) member, or have they been here for years with an established membership?

Since this thread is discussing another member in our community, we are going to close the thread. If you have concerns or don't want to be involved with another member, simply put them on your Ignore list and/or bring your concern to an Administrator. (And if you do the latter, we'd hope you'd provide us more information than, "I suspect so-and-so isn't being truthful..." We can't act on innuendo alone.)

Thanks.