View Single Post
 
Old Jan 21, 2018, 03:41 PM
mcl6136's Avatar
mcl6136 mcl6136 is offline
Magnate
 
Member Since: Aug 2011
Posts: 2,082
Quote:
Originally Posted by chihirochild View Post
There's some background below if you're interested, but the just of it is that I've been feeling a bit better lately--my SI is not nearly as persistent, I have a bit more energy, I don't spend as much time trapped in my mind/body with thoughts and emotions that make me miserable. Pdoc was attributing this change to therapy, and this conversation followed:

pdoc: "the transition [i moved to a new town, and had to get new shrinks] was difficult, but now you're settled with us [pdoc and t]."
c: "mhmm."
pdoc: "and you've been able to set some boundaries with your parents, even though that was difficult."
c: "true."
pdoc: "do you feel held here?"
c: "no."
pdoc: [genuinely surprised] "no? why not?"
c: "because... well, you're asking me to separate from my parents. and I get why you're suggesting that--they're not healthy people, and they contribute to my depression. but... I don't really know how to say this exactly... but if the apocalypse hit, they are the only people who would care if I were alive or not. the relationship i have with you and [t] is limited. what you're offering does not replace what you're asking me to give up. so no, I don't feel held."
pdoc: "but you seem to be feeling better now that you've set some boundaries with them?"
c: "yes. but maybe I feel better because I've had pretty minimal therapy over the last month and a half. maybe the longer I stay away from shrinks, the better I feel."
pdoc: "but you've been seeing me once a week."
c: "yeah, but usually I have twice-a-week therapy. for the last month and a half it's been nothing or once a week."
[long pause]
pdoc: "that felt like a slap in the face."
c: "aren't you supposed to be impermeable?"
pdoc: "no, of course not--otherwise how could I do my job?"
c: [shrug]
pdoc: "I must have said something that made you angry."
c: "Really? I don't feel angry."
pdoc: "let me think, what could it have been?"
c: "isn't it possible that I said what I said because I believe it to be true?"
pdoc: 'well, yes, but also... timing."
c: "huh. so you think I'm angry because I said something that hurt your feelings?"
pdoc: "mhmm."

So.... I guess my questions are:
1) It was my understanding that the strict boundaries in therapy are set up in part so that the client doesn't have to burden herself with her therapist's wants/needs/emotions. So.... doesn't that mean that when the client says something offensive or hurtful, the therapist doesn't necessarily share her/his emotional reaction?
2) Pdoc has never apologized to me, even though he's done some things that didn't sit well with me. (Super intense --> brush-off, Inconsistency, response to SH) Why the hell should I apologize to him?
3) Did I say that because I was angry? (If not, it seems sketchy that pdoc can take the thinks I say that he doesn't like and attribute them to "chihirochild being angry" rather than "chihirochild has a point.")

halp, pls :/

----------------------------------------------------------------
Background if wanted/needed
Due to a weird insurance sitch, I do therapy with both a t and a pdoc. I see t once or twice a week and pdoc once every two weeks so that I see one or the other of them twice a week. They work in the same office and share info and stuff, so I don't have to repeat myself all the time.

There was a five-week period where I had very little therapy--first I was away for two weeks, and then my t was away for three weeks; during the second three-week period, I saw pdoc once a week. Right after t came back but I hadn't seen her yet, I had a session with pdoc and this is what he and i talked about.
Frankly it almost seemed like pdoc was fishing for compliments...like you were supposed to attribute your better condition to the therapy. Telling you how you feel is also how it came across. I don't like it when my t seems to want to produce or elicit something from me. I guess that's maybe why it didn't work? The interaction seems more about pdoc than you at least at this point.
Thanks for this!
Anonymous45127, Bill3, here today, LonesomeTonight, lucozader