View Single Post
 
Old Apr 11, 2018, 11:57 AM
amandalouise's Avatar
amandalouise amandalouise is offline
Wise Elder
 
Member Since: Mar 2009
Location: 8CS / NYS / USA
Posts: 9,171
Quote:
Originally Posted by Starry_Night View Post
I dont see how it could be proven false when it hasn happened to me quite a bit.

Kathy is not actually an Aussie. I am friends with her. I am glad some of you like her blog. She is really a very caring person and quite an expert.
Im sorry but I cant supply the proof because it was part of my job info and that goes against the rules here.

what I can do is point you to your local library's copy of the DSM 5 that explains what DID is including the diagnostics, and 5 pages of information beyond that that goes more into detail about how and why DID is listed as a dissociative disorder, what happens with it and even cultural and demographics.... lots of good stuff in there.

I can also point you to your own treatment provider who may have access to whats called Supplemental Updates that the APA supplies treatment providers on various mental disorders that you can not find on the internet, these updates are things that have been changed or proven or what and hows of mental disorders that most people dont have access to.

what else I can do is tell you what I mean when I said it was proven to be false....

when you look at the DSM 5 you will find the DID is listed in the dissociation category. this is because the key symptom in these disorders are dissociation.

here where I am dissociation is not something someone can choose or not choose to be. its an automatic reaction to a trigger.

you know how if someone says something you dont like you feel angry....

the someone says something is the trigger
your feeling angry is the reaction.

dissociation is like that.......

something happens (trigger)
to make the reaction (dissociation symptom)

Something happens (a positive or negative trigger, like feeling emotional, or situation that one or another cant handle or do, life event....)
to make the reaction (feeling numb, spaced out, disconnected, switch into alters....)

with swtiching alters....

Something happens (a positive or negative trigger)
to make the reaction...(switching into or out of alters)

it may seem sometimes like a choice but in actuality its been proven that dissociaiton has to happen in order for the switching in and out of alters can happen.... other wise it would not be listed as a dissociative disorder.

my point about her blog entry was.......... its not as simple as....... just choosing to be DID, just choosing to be this alter or that one. just choosing to push each other out of the way...if it was a choice it would be a behavior problem not a dissociative problem.