View Single Post
 
Old Apr 20, 2018, 10:35 PM
ArcheM ArcheM is offline
Veteran Member
 
Member Since: Dec 2016
Location: Russia
Posts: 634
Oof, at the risk of... interfering with the book, but that's another of the topics I enjoy.

The equivalent of the use of "sein" ("to be") in English isn't completely unknown or hasn't disappeared. The most common expression would be "something is gone". Well, with a certain meaning it's just an adjective, and when you want to be more specific, you can, of course, say "something has gone". But there's still traces of the present perfect being expressed there.

Oh, yeah, so I have to defer to my own grammar book, according to which (well, I know it myself, but rather implicitly), perfect tenses are used with "sein" when it has to do with movement or transformation (plus some special cases, like "bleiben", "passieren"): "ich bin gekommen" - "I have come", "Was ist passiert?" - "What has happened?", "Er ist gestorben" - "He has died".
__________________
Social anxiety and possible Aspergers (undiagnosed, but it helps to let you know to more quickly find a common ground).

Life is a journey without a destination.