I support this post very much and have thought a lot about the exact same thing lately. I personally love it when someone disagrees with me and offers an opposing or other viewpoint that is simply different than my own. I recognize that we are taking to and about individuals here. Everyone has their own journey and their own path, but I do think that having as many differentiated responses as possible can be incredibly beneficial to the OP and the audience at large.
Personally, I am not here only for the hugs or for any delusion I have to be re-enforced (god forbid) under the guise of unrelenting kindness. I am here to recovery by any means necessary. Especially if that pushes me outside of my comfort bubble. Thank you for such an extensively thought out and well considered post!