If I were to try to get into your account; they'd want me to go away because obviously it either isn't my account or I'm a klutz and can't remember my own info

It's a security feature; obviously no one was able to break into your account. Wait a few minutes and get in and send myspace an e-mail telling them someone was obviously trying to break into your account, is there anything you can do to help? I'd also make sure you have a super-deluxe password (totally nonsensical (not a "real" word or word portion) with lots of symbols and numbers and upper as well as lower case letters).