I talked with them via web chat a few minutes ago and they want the jeans back. They probably think I am an idiot for contacting them since there wasn’t a double charge. But I try to be as honest as I can in specific situations. Especially ones like these.

They can trace this sort of stuff.

Now I just hope they don’t take the charge off my card once I return them thinking I only got one pair and am returning it instead of a replacement.