You can review what threads you're subscribed to by going here:

https://mysupportforums.org/usercp.php

If you don't see any subscriptions listed, it's likely you're not subscribed to the threads you thought you were. You can fix that super easy by just going to the thread you want to subscribe to, and, from the Thread Tools menu, click on the link that says, "Subscribe to This Thread." That should do it, and then you should start receiving emails as new replies are made.